Doodles
Doodles: fluffy, proper, pristine the social marker of well-to-do families… and unethical.
Doodle dogs are a designer breed from mixing a poodle with other purebred dogs, such as the Cockapoo (Cocker Spaniel x Poodle), Sheepadoodle (Old English Sheepdog x Poodle), and Goldendoodle (Golden Retriever x Poodle), to name a few. You most likely have seen one on a walk in your neighborhood or posted online. Their breeders claim that they’re hypoallergenic (shed much less than the average dog), have outgoing temperaments, and that the breeders care for their dogs, but this is far from the truth. The reality is that they have no standard to be held to, the majority of their traits are unpredictable, and they are often housed in less than ideal conditions for dog breeding.
First, what do I mean by “they have no standard to be held to”? A purebred dog breed recognized by the many kennel clubs across the world has a standard, a 1-4 page document describing how the dog is supposed to behave and look. It varies from kennel club to kennel club, but they are all very similar. These ensure that when dogs are shown, dogs that meet this standard can be bred with confidence that they will contribute to the health of the breed. Before they are bred, they also receive health testing to ensure they don’t pass on any conditions the breed is prone to. Doodles of any kind lack a standard, which means there is no single look or behavior that a doodle is supposed to have. Along with no standard, many doodle breeders do not health test their dogs, leading to the majority of them having allergies, hip/elbow dysplasia, and conditions from parent breeds. This is why their traits are mostly unpredictable. If you mix a poodle, an intelligent dog with a curly coat (hair), with a double-coated dog that is prone to being aggressive, you could get many different outcomes. Some puppies could get the curly hair coat of the poodle and aggressiveness; on the other hand, you could get a puppy with a double coat and intelligence. This can lower the quality of life for the dog, when most people don’t care and buy them for aesthetic reasons or even as a marker of financial success.
Next, doodles are often bred and raised in less than ideal conditions. This is not a true reason why they are unethical, but it does tie into how many doodles act, not to mention, it’s also animal cruelty. Many doodle breeders have a copious amount of dogs in their breeding program. Some have up to 40 or 50 dogs in a single program (which is the equivalent of a puppy mill). An ethical breeder normally has 4 to 8 dogs in a breeding program. This small number is to remain realistic about how much time they have to spend with each dog, as they can be show or hunting dogs, depending on the breed. With over 20 dogs, these dogs will not be getting the attention that they need when their owner has 19 other dogs to play with and feed, and this means many of these dogs are locked up in crates for extended periods of time, as the average person doesn’t want to keep up with 20 untrained dogs. This physical and mental stress could affect the parents that you buy your puppy from. When puppies are born, a responsible breeder should expose them to the sights and sounds of the world, called socialization, and give them a temperament test to match them with the right family. Doodle breeders often do not do this. The majority won’t expose them, instead keeping the puppies in the comfort of their homes, and often let the family choose their puppy. In the home, there is a limited number of sensory inputs the puppies can grow accustomed to. If puppies grow up without being socialized, they are prone to reactivity responses(fear-, aggression-, or excitement-based) a dog that overreacts to common stimuli. This means when your puppy grows up, they might freak out when they see another dog or person. Over time, this reactivity can evolve into aggression-based behavior and often lowers the quality of life for the dog if no measures are in place to train them to tolerate stimuli of daily life.
Lastly, how do you avoid these breeders and find ethical breeders (of other dog breeds) and alternatives? To start, you should look for information on different dog breeds on a Kennel Club website; the main ones you will use are the AKC (American Kennel Club) and CKC (Continental Kennel Club). There are other kennel clubs, and they are also great places for information, but don’t have as much owner-friendly information on their websites. The AKC and CKC provide information on over 150 dog breeds about their temperament, energy, trainability, and other characteristics. Both of these groups have quizzes to see which dog breeds could be a good fit for your family. These quizzes should be taken with a grain of salt, and you should still do your own research. The AKC and CKC both have mixed breed registration, but only the CKC allows mixed breeds on their marketplace. A good place to start is the AKC marketplace. Even if the breeder is registered does not automatically mean they’re an ethical breeder. There are a few things to look for when searching for an ethical breeder. First, they shouldn’t have an abundance of dogs for their breeding program; 8 or more dogs is suspicious, but they shouldn’t be completely ignored because of it. Second, all the dogs in their breeding program should be well decorated with titles from different dog events, such as conformation (dog shows), hunting trials, and other feats to prove that this dog is in good condition and can perform different tasks. Along with that, all of these dogs should have OFA testing to ensure they will not pass on conditions that their breed is prone to. Of course, please do further research about this topic, and don’t just take my word for it. Another path to take is to adopt a dog from a shelter or rescue. Not everyone needs a shelter dog, as shelters can alter a dog’s behavior, and they are normally from unknown backgrounds, but there is a dog in a shelter that is meant for you. You should have a list of desired traits you would like in your ideal dog. Do not expect any dog to meet all of the criteria, but if they check most of your boxes, then they might be a match! Also, there are doodle-only rescues if you truly want a doodle without the unethical nature of their breeding. You will still get a dog filled with possible issues, but you will not be funding the creation of them. The last obvious path to take is to not have a dog. I think that this is self-explanatory. A project/movement to keep your eye on involving doodles is the creation of Australian Labradoodles, a mix between the poodle, the Labrador Retriever, and the cocker spaniel. The GALA (Global Australian Labradoodle Association) specifically seems dedicated to helping them become a legitimate breed, as they have a standard (which will most likely change over time) and have ethical breeding practices (besides dog show/hunting titles). This doesn’t mean buying from one of their breeders, as they are still doodles and aren’t recognized by any kennel club. This project could help this mix gain healthier traits with an ethical approach, as all dogs technically did start as mixes. The difference is that, since they were bred generation after generation, they started to have a predictable look and behavior when they are born instead of being a roll of the dice of what traits they will get.